13 October 2011

Benefit They're Real Mascara Review

My usual mascara's are either Lancome or YSL as I find them consistently the best performing.  I fancied a change and there was quite a lot of hype for the new Benefit mascara called They're Real so picked it up on a  late night trip to Boots. 

The mascara claims to lengthen, curl, volumise, lift and separate, be jet black and have a long wearing and smudge free formula.  That's a lot to claim for once mascara! Things to note: This mascara isn't water based, so can't be used if you wear semi permanent eyelash extensions, it is also not waterproof (or doesn't claim to be) but it's a b*tch to remove so heck it might be fine for some light crying lol! 

Not important to some, very important to me.  This isn't your bog standard cheapie looking mascara, the black chrome effect finish is smart and classy, not quite on par with YSL but more on the same level as Lancome. 

The funky want is a decent length with very thin spikes which really get down to the root of the lash and help you get into the inner and outer corner lashes quite easily, I was impressed and while similar to Covergirl Lashblast this wand is better.You can use the wand horizontally or vertically and it works both ways, I was very impressed by the wand.

Lengthen - yes slightly
Curl - absolutely
Volumise - yep
Lift and separate - definitely
Jet Black - yes this is so dark, you might think black is just black but this is really smoky dark, it's amazing
Long wearing - erm yes, how exactly do you get this off?  Not sure!  
The second day I just put on another coat as I couldn't get it off the night before, I woke up looking like I  had perfectly mascara'd lashes, it was just like semi permanent mascara reallySmudge free formula - agreed this does not smudge

Normal mascara left - They're Real - right 
You can't really see the volume but the curl is there

Things I like about this mascara
 Its really easy to you and you can see as you are applying it that it lifts and separates and I was shocked how I could see the curl and how it held it all day, I love the blackest black look of it and it is great with dark eyeshadows as sometimes your lashes get lost if the mascara isn't jet black.  Overall this is one of the best mascara's I have tried and I am really happy I randomly decided to give it a go.

Possible things you might not like about this mascara
It can go a bit clumpy if you apply more than 3 coats, or if you already have super long and thick lashes I could see this not being that useful, but then if they are already long and thick, why buy this and stick to 2 coats and you'll be fine.  Also its a right pain in the bum to remove, you can either wear it for a few days and then go to town with some oily makeup remover or just scrub every day, which I can't really be bothered to do - i'm lazy so I just remove it every 2 days.

Overall I give Benefit's new They're Real Mascara a 9 out of 10 


  1. Sounds fairly good. Thanks for the review xx

  2. I have been wanting to try this one but have so many on the go right now. It sounds good, thanks for the review x

  3. This sounds like a good mascara! Do you know the difference between this one and Benefit's Bad Gal Lash mascara? Thanks :) xo

    Sophia @ Beauty Blog UK

  4. thanks for the review!i'm lazy like you when it comes to mascara so this is definetely for me:) i'm gonna try this


Thank you for leaving a comment, I will respond as soon as I can but you can always email or tweet me if you want a faster response.

If you are here to leave link to your blog please do so via email, all comments with blog links are deleted.